What Is a Glomar Response? “Neither Confirm Nor Deny” Explained
Sometimes, U.S. Federal Government employees respond to a question such that they “neither confirm nor deny” anything about the inquiry. What is the history of this response?
A GLOMAR response is a non-committal reply used primarily by U.S. government agencies, especially in response to Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests, where they neither confirm nor deny the existence of the requested information or records. It originates from a 1976 case involving the CIA and a journalist’s FOIA request about the Glomar Explorer, a ship involved in a classified operation called Project AZORIAN.
The origin: a lost Soviet submarine and a billionaire’s cover story

In 1968, a K-129 Soviet Golf II-class submarine carrying three SS-N-4 nuclear-armed ballistic missiles left the naval base at Petropavlovsk on Russia’s Kamchatka Peninsula patrol station the Pacific Ocean northeast of Hawaii. Soon after, the submarine and entire crew were lost, sunk 1800 miles northwest of Hawaii at a depth of 16,500 feet. The Hughes Glomar Explorer was secretly deployed to recover the submarine. The CIA’s cover story was that it was commercial deep-sea mining vessel ostensibly built and owned by billionaire Howard Hughes, who was conducting marine research at extreme ocean depths and mining manganese nodules lying on the sea bottom.
In June 1974, just before the Glomar set sail, thieves had broken into one of the Hughes offices in Los Angeles and stolen secret documents, one tying Howard Hughes to CIA and the Glomar Explorer. This turned into a scandal around August 1974, and the Los Angeles Police Department began an investigation. On 7 February 1975 the Los Angeles Times published an account that made connections between the robbery, Hughes, CIA, and the recovery operation, despite the CIA’s request that journalists leave the story alone on national security grounds.
Not wanting to lie to the American people, but also not wanting to jeopardize what remained of secrecy, the policy of the Ford Administration was to neither confirm nor deny any stories that came up about the Glomar mission.
Hence the name: GLOMAR RESPONSE–“We can neither confirm nor deny.”
What happened to the Glomar Explorer mission

The Hughes Glomar Explorer reached the recovery site on July 4, 1974. Its giant mechanical claw began lifting the submarine on August 1, and the recovered section was secured inside the ship on August 8. Only part of the K-129 came up. Most of the hull broke away during the lift and fell back to the ocean floor (National Security Archive).
The ship’s name was part of the cover. “Glomar” came from Global Marine, the offshore drilling company that operated the vessel, and the Hughes name lent the deep-sea mining story credibility. The CIA’s own internal history of the operation, “Project AZORIAN: The Story of the Hughes Glomar Explorer,” first appeared in the agency’s classified journal Studies in Intelligence and was released in redacted form in 2010 after a Freedom of Information Act request (CIA history, via the National Security Archive).
The court case that made it law: Phillippi v. CIA
After the press reports in 1975, journalist Harriet Ann Phillippi filed a FOIA request for CIA records about the agency’s efforts to persuade the media not to publish the Glomar story. The CIA replied that “involvement by the U.S. Government in the activities which are the subject matter of your request can neither be confirmed nor denied.” Phillippi sued.

In Phillippi v. CIA, 546 F.2d 1009 (D.C. Cir. 1976), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit accepted that an agency could, in principle, refuse to confirm or deny that records exist when the fact of their existence is itself protected. But it did not give the CIA a blank check. The court sent the case back and required the agency to justify its refusal publicly, in as much detail as possible, before a judge could rely on secret affidavits. That combination, a legitimate right to stay silent paired with a duty to explain why, is still the framework today.
Ever since, refusing to confirm or deny has been called a “Glomar response,” and lawyers speak of an agency “Glomarizing” a request.
How a Glomar response works today
Normally, an agency that withholds records under FOIA at least admits the records exist. A Glomar response goes further. It is used when simply saying “yes, we have records” or “no, we don’t” would itself reveal something protected.
There are two main kinds:
- National security Glomar. Executive Order 13526, which governs classified information, says an agency “may refuse to confirm or deny the existence or nonexistence of requested records whenever the fact of their existence or nonexistence is itself classified” (EO 13526, sec. 3.6(a)). Agencies pair this with FOIA Exemption 1 (classified information) and Exemption 3 (information protected by other statutes, such as the law protecting intelligence sources and methods).
- Privacy Glomar. Law enforcement agencies use the same tactic to protect people. If you ask the FBI for its files on a named private individual, confirming that a file exists could suggest that person was investigated. So the agency may neither confirm nor deny, citing FOIA’s privacy exemptions (Exemptions 6 and 7(C)), unless the person consents, has died, or there is an overriding public interest.
The key point is that a Glomar response is not a lie and not a denial. It is a deliberate refusal to answer the threshold question.
When a Glomar response fails: official acknowledgment
An agency cannot keep refusing to confirm something the government has already confirmed. Courts call this the official acknowledgment doctrine. Under the test set out in Fitzgibbon v. CIA, 911 F.2d 755 (D.C. Cir. 1990), information counts as officially acknowledged if it is as specific as the information requested, matches it, and was made public through an official, documented disclosure. Leaks and press reports do not count; statements by officials do.
The best-known example is ACLU v. CIA (D.C. Cir. 2013). The ACLU requested records about drone strikes, and the CIA gave a Glomar response, refusing even to say whether it had an “intelligence interest” in drones. The court rejected that position as “neither logical nor plausible,” because the President, the CIA Director and the President’s counterterrorism adviser had all publicly discussed the drone program (opinion). The CIA could still argue that specific records were exempt, but it could no longer pretend the subject was a secret.
What to do if you get a Glomar response
- Read it carefully. Note which exemptions the agency cites. A national security Glomar and a privacy Glomar are challenged differently.
- File an administrative appeal. Federal agencies must give requesters at least 90 days to appeal an adverse FOIA decision. The response letter will say where to send it.
- Look for official acknowledgment. Search speeches, congressional testimony, press releases, court filings and declassified documents. If a senior official has already confirmed the subject, cite it specifically.
- Narrow or reframe the request. Sometimes a request can be rewritten so that confirming records exist reveals nothing new.
- Consider litigation. In court, the agency must justify its Glomar response publicly in as much detail as it can, the rule Phillippi established.
This is general information, not legal advice. For an important request, a FOIA attorney is worth the call.
Why “neither confirm nor deny” matters to analysts
For anyone who reads government responses for a living, the Glomar response carries an analytic lesson: a non-answer is not an answer. It is tempting to read “we can neither confirm nor deny” as a wink that means yes. That is a mistake. Agencies are expected to give the same response whether or not records exist, precisely so that the response itself reveals nothing. If they only Glomarized when the answer was yes, the non-answer would become a confirmation and the whole tool would collapse.
So treat a Glomar response as what it is: no evidence either way. Then go looking for evidence that actually discriminates between your hypotheses. (That habit is at the heart of avoiding confirmation bias.)
Glomar in popular culture
The phrase escaped the courtroom long ago. Its most famous outing came in June 2014, when the CIA joined Twitter. Its first tweet read: “We can neither confirm nor deny that this is our first tweet.” Forty years after the Glomar Explorer went to sea, the agency was in on the joke.
Frequently asked questions
What is a Glomar response?
A reply in which a government agency neither confirms nor denies that requested records exist, used when the existence of the records is itself classified or would invade someone’s privacy.
Where does the term Glomar come from?
From the Hughes Glomar Explorer, the ship the CIA used in 1974 to secretly recover part of the sunken Soviet submarine K-129. The CIA’s refusal to confirm or deny records about it was tested in Phillippi v. CIA (1976).
Is a Glomar response the same as a denial?
No. It is a refusal to answer the threshold question of whether records exist. Agencies are supposed to give the same response whether or not records exist, so it should not be read as a yes.
Can you challenge a Glomar response?
Yes. You can file an administrative appeal and, if needed, sue. A Glomar response fails if the government has already officially acknowledged the information, as in ACLU v. CIA (2013) on drone strikes.
Related analysis from Competitive Futures
- How to Read Declassified Documents — tradecraft for reading government records
- Trend Data About the U.S. Government Shutdown — the numbers behind shutdowns
- The World’s First Permanent Military Intelligence Service — where modern spy agencies began
Want this kind of analysis for your organization? Contact Competitive Futures or learn more about Eric Garland.
About Competitive Futures
Competitive Futures has provided strategic intelligence and foresight to corporate and government clients since 2002. Its principal, Eric Garland, publishes analysis here, on Game Theory Today, and in the Systemics Quarterly Brief.
Read next
- Seventy Countries, Six Cities: The Global Network Behind Iran
- The Systemics Quarterly Brief: 2026 Prospectus
- Strategic intelligence services for executives and governments
- All analysis from Competitive Futures
Stay in touch
Leave your email and a note about the Brief, a briefing for your team, or this piece, and we will be in touch.