How America Wins in Iran
The United States has fought thirty-one wars since 1775. The military ledger: nineteen wins, four draws, three losses, two withdrawals, two victories that collapsed afterward — and one war, the current one, with no verdict yet. But wins that actually held without further force number about six, and they come in exactly two forms: the objective was small and verifiable (end the tribute in 1815, leave Kuwait in 1991, hand over Noriega in 1989), or the troops never left (Germany and Japan since 1945, Korea since the 1953 armistice — a war that technically never ended, because no peace treaty was ever signed).
The pattern says “did we win” is the wrong question. Wars end in one of five things — a settlement, a garrison, an annexation, an armistice, or reversion — and winning the battles only determines which of those you get to pick from. The Versailles settlement collapsed in twenty years; Saigon fell; Kabul fell to the exact forces removed in 2001. The question that ages well is: who is enforcing the outcome, with what, and for how long? Applied to Iran — no one-sentence verifiable objective, no occupation coming, and a June 17 memorandum with no enforcement mechanism — the historical table puts this in the Korea column, not the Panama column. That column stays open a very long time.
I’m Eric Garland. I’ve spent 30 years in strategic intelligence practice, and I’m personally sanctioned by the Russian Federation for my work on Russian intelligence operations. On Game Theory Today I walk through the questions a professional analyst actually asks about the news, not the answers you’re handed.
🔔 Subscribe for daily geopolitical intelligence analysis. Follow on X @ericgarland. Full long-form analysis on Substack. 🎤 Book Eric to speak: · Leading Authorities — https://www.leadingauthorities.com/speakers/eric-garland · Executive Speakers Bureau — https://www.executivespeakers.com/speaker/eric-garland · SPEAKING.com — https://speaking.com/speakers/eric-garland/
SOURCES
Korean Armistice Agreement — Panmunjom, July 27, 1953 (no successor peace treaty)
U.S. Senate — Treaty of Versailles ratification fails — March 19, 1920
Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo — February 2, 1848
U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan — Kabul falls August 15; final flight August 30, 2021
U.S.–Iran memorandum of understanding, reported — June 17, 2026
U.S. Treasury / OFAC — designations over Iran fund transfers to Hezbollah — 2026
CNN — U.S. intelligence assessment on retained Iranian missile and drone capability — April 2, 2026
U.S. Wars Outcome Ledger, 1775–2026 — Competitive Futures research file, August 2026
