Futurist or Strategic Foresight Speaker? How to Tell the Difference Before You Book

Strategic foresight speaker on a brightly lit stage above a darkened audience

Event planners often ask a version of this question: “We want a futurist. Is that the same thing as a strategic foresight speaker?” Sometimes. The labels overlap, the speakers’ bureaus use them interchangeably, and the difference matters more to your audience than to the person selling the talk. Here is how to tell them apart, and which one you actually need.

What a futurist speaker does

A futurist speaker’s job is to change how an audience sees the next ten years. The good ones arrive with trends, examples and a story, and they leave the room energized and a little unsettled. The emphasis is on what is coming: the technologies, the demographic shifts, the changes in how people live and buy. The best futurist keynotes are a form of intellectual theater, and that is a compliment.

The weakness of the genre is that “futurist” is not a protected title. Anyone can use it. A great many futurist keynotes are a tour of shiny technologies with a motivational finish, delivered identically to a bank on Monday and a hospital system on Wednesday.

What a strategic foresight speaker does

Strategic foresight is a discipline, with methods and a professional body. The Association of Professional Futurists’ competency model, developed by Andy Hines and colleagues, describes six core skills: framing the question, scanning the environment, futuring (building alternative futures), visioning, designing responses, and adapting as events unfold (Hines, Gary, Daheim and van der Laan, World Futures Review, 2017). A strategic foresight speaker brings that method into the room. The emphasis is on so what: how the trends combine, which scenarios they produce, what each scenario means for the organization in the audience, and what to watch for next.

The result is usually less spectacular and more useful. A foresight keynote leaves the audience with a way of thinking they can run themselves after the speaker goes home. That is the method described in this site’s guide to strategic foresight and in the Future Intelligence Process.

Five tells

You can usually sort a speaker into one camp or the other from a demo video and a phone call.

  1. One future or several? A futurist tends to describe the future. A foresight practitioner describes three or four and tells you how to tell which one is arriving. If the talk never uses the word “scenario,” it is a futurist talk.
  2. Trends or implications? Listing trends is the easy part; anyone with a browser can do it. Ask what the speaker does with them. Foresight work turns trends into implications for your industry, which takes research into your industry.
  3. Where did the method come from? Strategic foresight has a lineage: the RAND Corporation and Herman Kahn, Shell’s scenario planners, the futures programs at the University of Houston and elsewhere, and founders of the field such as Joseph F. Coates. A speaker who cannot name where their method comes from probably does not have one.
  4. Do they keep score? Foresight practitioners treat forecasts as hypotheses and go back to check them. Ask what the speaker has gotten wrong. A futurist who has never been wrong has never been checked. (For what that looks like in practice, see this scorecard of fifteen-year-old forecasts, a third of which were stinkers.)
  5. Who does the thinking afterward? After a futurist keynote, the audience talks about the speaker. After a foresight keynote, they talk about their own business. Both are good outcomes; only one of them is strategy.

Which one do you need?

It depends on the room and the job.

  • A large conference opener or closer, where the goal is to lift the energy and give a thousand people a shared frame for the day: book a futurist, and pick one who also has a method, so the content survives scrutiny from the smart people in the audience.
  • A leadership offsite, board retreat or strategy session, where real decisions are on the table: book a strategic foresight speaker, and pay for the customized version. The value is in the research and the scenarios, not the applause.
  • An analyst team or planning group that needs to do this work itself: skip the keynote and book a working session. Half a day on scenario building with the team’s own questions will outlast any talk.

The honest answer

The best speakers in this field are both: strategic foresight practitioners who have learned to hold a room. That combination is rarer than it should be, because the two skills are developed in different places, one in the research library and one on stage. When you find it, the difference between a futurist talk and a foresight talk disappears, and what you get is a keynote that is entertaining on the day and still useful a year later.

If you are comparing candidates, start with the five questions to ask any futurist speaker, then look at what the fee actually buys.

Eric Garland gives keynotes on strategic foresight and geopolitics; details are on the keynote speaker page.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a futurist and a strategic foresight speaker?

A futurist speaker focuses on what is coming: trends, technologies and social change. A strategic foresight speaker uses a structured method to turn those trends into alternative scenarios and implications for a specific organization.

Is strategic foresight a recognized discipline?

Yes. It has a professional body, the Association of Professional Futurists, academic programs such as the University of Houston’s foresight program, and a published competency model covering framing, scanning, futuring, visioning, designing and adapting.

Which type of speaker should I book for a leadership retreat?

For an offsite or strategy session where real decisions are on the table, a strategic foresight speaker who customizes the talk to your organization is usually the better choice.

How can I tell if a futurist speaker has a real method?

Ask whether they present one future or several scenarios, where their method comes from, and what forecasts they have gotten wrong. Speakers with a real method can answer all three.

About Competitive Futures

Competitive Futures has provided strategic intelligence and foresight to corporate and government clients since 2002. Its principal, Eric Garland, publishes analysis here, on Game Theory Today, and in the Systemics Quarterly Brief.

Read next

Stay in touch

Leave your email and a note about the Brief, a briefing for your team, or this piece, and we will be in touch.