7 Questions to Ask a Geopolitics Speaker Before the Event

Executives meeting beneath a world map to choose a geopolitics speaker

Geopolitics keynotes are in demand for an obvious reason: a war in the Gulf, export controls on the minerals in your products, and sanctions regimes that change by the week have made the outside world a line item in every strategic plan. The supply of speakers has risen to meet the demand, and the quality varies enormously. Some are analysts. Some are retired officials with good stories. Some are pundits who have been wrong for twenty years in front of large audiences.

What separates the useful ones from the rest is not their résumé. It is their method, and you can test for it in a phone call. These are the seven questions to ask before you book a geopolitics speaker.

1. How do you decide what to believe?

This is the whole game. A geopolitics speaker is an analyst, whether or not they use the word, and analysts have methods. Ask what theirs is. You want to hear about weighing sources, about testing more than one explanation against the evidence, and about stating uncertainty honestly. The U.S. intelligence community’s analytic standards require analysts to express and explain the uncertainty in every major judgment, and to use words like “likely” and “unlikely” with defined meanings (Intelligence Community Directive 203). A speaker who tells you what “will” happen, with no odds attached, is not analyzing. They are performing.

2. What have you gotten wrong?

Everyone who forecasts geopolitics has been wrong, repeatedly. The question is whether the speaker knows it. A good answer names a specific call, explains what the mistake taught them, and shows that the method changed as a result. A bad answer is a smile and a pivot. The standard to hold them to is a published track record, misses included, like this scorecard of fifteen-year-old forecasts. If a speaker is going to ask a room to trust their judgment, the room deserves to see how it has performed.

3. Do you predict events or explain mechanisms?

Dated predictions make great headlines and poor strategy. In Philip Tetlock’s twenty-year study of expert political forecasts, the most famous forecasters made the worst predictions, and confidence was a warning sign rather than a credential (Tetlock, Expert Political Judgment, via CBS MoneyWatch). What survives contact with events is an explanation of how the system works: who the actors are, what they want, what tools they have, and what each of them would do if the others moved. A talk built on mechanisms is still useful when the news changes the week after the conference. A talk built on predictions is obsolete by the Q&A.

4. What do you read, and is any of it primary?

Ask where the speaker’s information comes from. The honest answer for most pundits is: the same news you read, delivered with more confidence. The analysts worth paying for read the documents themselves: sanctions designations, indictments and court filings, regulatory notices, central bank statements, the published strategies of the governments in question. Federal court records alone are a goldmine that almost nobody on the speaking circuit opens (here is a guide to using PACER, for the few who want to). A speaker who works from primary sources will tell you things you have not read elsewhere. That is the point of hiring one.

5. Can you connect it to our business?

Geopolitics as spectacle is cheap. Geopolitics as a map of your own exposure is valuable, and it takes work. Before the event, a serious speaker will want to know where your suppliers are, which chokepoints your products pass through, which jurisdictions’ enforcement agencies can reach you, and which of your customers depend on a government that might not be there in five years. Ask whether the talk will be tailored that way, and expect to pay for the research if it is. The ship stuck in the Suez Canal, the chip shortage and the Strait of Hormuz were all geopolitics; they were also, for specific companies, the difference between a good year and a terrible one.

6. Can you hold a room that disagrees with you?

Every audience is politically mixed, and geopolitics touches politics everywhere. A speaker who cannot describe a government’s strategy without editorializing about it will lose half the room in the first ten minutes, and the half they lose will include some of your best people. Watch a full-length video, not the highlight reel, and listen for whether the speaker describes what actors are doing and why, or tells the audience what to think about it. The first is analysis. The second is a column, and your audience can read columns for free.

7. What will we be watching for after you leave?

The best geopolitics keynote ends with a short list of signposts: the specific, observable events that would tell your leadership which scenario is unfolding. An export-control announcement. A change in shipping insurance rates. A sanctions designation of a counterparty. A speaker who leaves you with signposts has given you a tool. One who leaves you with a feeling has given you an evening.

The difference it makes

The world is going to keep giving your organization reasons to need this kind of thinking. Put these seven questions to every candidate, and the answers will sort them quickly. The difference between a good geopolitics speaker and a bad one is the difference between a plan and a mood.

Eric Garland gives keynotes on strategic foresight and geopolitics; details are on the keynote speaker page.

Frequently asked questions

What should I look for in a geopolitics keynote speaker?

A clear analytic method, honest statements of uncertainty, a willingness to discuss past mistakes, use of primary sources, and the ability to connect global events to your organization’s own exposure.

Should a geopolitics speaker make predictions?

Dated predictions age badly. Research by Philip Tetlock found that the most famous forecasters made the worst predictions. Talks that explain how actors and systems work stay useful after the news changes.

Can a geopolitics talk be tailored to my industry?

Yes, and it should be for leadership audiences. Expect the speaker to ask about your suppliers, shipping routes, jurisdictions and customers, and to charge for the research.

How do I avoid a geopolitics speaker who alienates half the room?

Watch a full-length talk, not a highlight reel, and check whether the speaker describes what governments are doing and why, or tells the audience what to think about it.

About Competitive Futures

Competitive Futures has provided strategic intelligence and foresight to corporate and government clients since 2002. Its principal, Eric Garland, publishes analysis here, on Game Theory Today, and in the Systemics Quarterly Brief.

Read next

Stay in touch

Leave your email and a note about the Brief, a briefing for your team, or this piece, and we will be in touch.