Competitive Intelligence on a Big Box Retailer: Guitar Center, 2013–2014

Case study · Retail · Private equity

A row of sunburst electric guitars on display in a music shop, from a competitive intelligence case study of Guitar Center

Guitar Center was never a client of Competitive Futures. It was the subject of the analysis: an intelligence target, researched entirely from open sources and industry contacts, after its own executives challenged us to do it.

The CEO dared us to research his company. We did.

This is the best case study we know of for how real, no-nonsense, skeptical competitive intelligence improves an understanding of a market. And it happened by accident.

On his personal blog, Eric Garland put up a brief post about the financial condition of Guitar Center, the large musical instrument retailer where he occasionally shopped. He had heard that the big box chain was in trouble, that its financial stability had eroded to the point that the New York ratings agencies called its corporate paper junk, and he added a few lines about suburban retail probably having seen its best days. What happened next surprised him.

Traffic to the site surged to tens of thousands of readers a day. The musical instrument industry is small, roughly $7 billion in the United States and $13 billion globally, and Guitar Center represented about $2 billion a year of it. With few analysts covering the sector, the company’s press releases had gone largely unchallenged for years. Someone decoding the Moody’s ratings in plain English shocked the industry and the thousands of musicians who cared about their retail options. Soon Guitar Center’s executives were in the comments section spreading talking points while posing as people from other companies, and its CEO made a statement on Garland’s Facebook page. The company took one position and held it: business was great, and Mr. Garland simply hadn’t done his research.

To a degree they were right. The post was a quip about a Reuters story passed along by a jazz guitarist at a jam session, not a dissection of the industry. But when you challenge a professional strategic analyst to get his research right, fasten your seat belt.

Secondary data plus human intelligence equals predictive insight

Working for the pleasure of getting the story right, Garland teamed with Competitive Futures’ technology practice lead, Monica Nixon. Long-time competitive intelligence practitioners, they knew that executives do not overreact like that unless something much bigger is lurking just beneath the surface. They pulled every publicly available document and news story from the preceding years, most of it concerning Bain Capital’s management of the company since its 2007 buyout. They compared balance sheets and worked through the arcane finance that had taken a healthy retailer to junk-bond status.

They had a second asset: a primary intelligence network that assembled itself from the notoriety of the original post. The transformation of a once-healthy market leader into an unstable creature of private-equity leverage worried a great many people, and many were willing to share what they knew.

Within days it was clear that the company’s official line, that Guitar Center was healthier than ever, was untrue, and that it was likely to face bankruptcy within weeks.

Events unfolded as projected, with one twist. The company was indeed insolvent, but there was one exit short of bankruptcy: Bain Capital could surrender its equity and its lender, Ares Management, could convert debt into ownership. The company limped on, now carrying even more high-yield debt. Garland explored what this meant for the instrument industry, for finance and for society in one of his most widely read essays, “How to get beyond the parasite economy.”

What the case teaches

Most competitive intelligence happens behind closed doors. The Guitar Center episode, which ran from November 2013 to April 2014, was a public accident of timing and personality that could probably never be repeated. Its lessons apply to every executive and every analyst who serves one.

1. You can never be too skeptical.

Size, glossy advertising and glib executives project confidence. The soul of intelligence is to be skeptical without tipping into cynicism. To the day its owners handed the keys to their lender, the company insisted everything was fine. Once its executives challenged us to do proper research, we believed nothing they said without corroboration.

2. Get the data.

The real story was available to anyone willing to do the analysis. The SEC’s EDGAR database held, for free, the documents showing the retailer was dangerously over-leveraged and out of liquidity. A highly predictive market analysis required no inside sources, only the drive and the skill to pull the right data.

3. Human intelligence networks rule.

Garland published only a small fraction of what sources across the industry told him. Vendors, former employees and competitors were invaluable for interpreting the public data and the gaps in the company’s statements. Hard data is almost nothing without first-person understanding of what is actually happening.

4. Dive into the implications.

The natural tendency, and the fervent wish of the company’s PR staff, was to normalize the fact that a market leader’s finances had sunk to the risk level of a startup. That meant something: the industry was headed for a major shift. When you see change, ask what it means.

5. Do not be intimidated into silence.

Analysts inside organizations are often cowed out of their best observations because they are politically inconvenient. Here it was the company’s executives trying to shout down the obvious conclusion. A real analyst keeps thinking when the politics get complicated; it is what makes this a calling as much as a profession.

Postscript

The underlying weakness the analysis identified never went away. In November 2020 Guitar Center filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection.

More case studies: Our Work. To discuss a similar engagement, request a consultation.